Asphalt vs. Concrete Cost: What’s the Difference?

asphalt vs. concrete cost

Whether you’re a property owner replacing an existing parking lot or a homeowner repairing a driveway, one of the first decisions you must make is choosing between asphalt and concrete as your pavement materials. When it comes to asphalt vs. concrete cost, several factors impact pricing. 

Below we’ll compare asphalt and concrete pricing for parking lots and driveways so you can make an informed decision that fits within your budget and needs. 

Asphalt vs. Concrete: What’s the Difference?

Before breaking down the asphalt vs. concrete cost, we’ll briefly explain both materials. Understanding the differences between asphalt vs. concrete will demonstrate how it impacts their pricing.  

The main differentiator between asphalt and concrete is the binding agent used to hold the aggregate (crushed sand) together. Asphalt uses a petroleum-based binder, while concrete is bound by cement. Although concrete and asphalt have similar materials, the costs can differ based on driveways and parking lots. 

Below we’ll break down the differences in pricing for asphalt services and concrete so you can decide which is best for your property or home.  

Asphalt vs. Concrete Cost: Pricing Factors

Property and homeowners commonly ask, “Is asphalt cheaper than concrete?” On average, asphalt costs $6-8/per square foot, while concrete can cost up to $12-15/per square foot. In addition to square footage costs, other factors impact pricing. Below we’ll break down the cost of asphalt vs. concrete for parking lots and driveways. 

Asphalt vs. Concrete Cost for Parking Lots

So, which is cheaper: asphalt or concrete? When it comes to larger parking lots, asphalt is often the more cost-effective choice. It not only costs less upfront but also offers several practical advantages that make it a better long-term investment for many property owners.

Here are a few reasons why asphalt may be the better option for parking lots:

  • Faster curing times, meaning the parking lot can reopen sooner and cause less disruption to your business or property use.
  • Lower cost per square foot, especially when paving larger areas, making it a more budget-friendly option.
  • Better resilience to sudden temperature changes, particularly in colder climates, helping asphalt surfaces withstand cracking and other damage with fewer repairs.
  • Simpler and less expensive repairs, allowing you to maintain the lot more easily and affordably over time.

Concrete for parking lots can be considered if your region doesn’t have extreme weather conditions (too hot or cold) or if you can’t commit to regular asphalt maintenance. Since concrete lasts longer than asphalt, this may be a better option for commercial districts that want to worry less about parking lot maintenance.  

Asphalt Parking Lots Concrete Parking Lots 
24-48 hours to cure One week to cure 
Ongoing maintenance required Less ongoing maintenance required 
Easier and cheaper repairs Complex and costly repairs 
$6-8/ sq ft  $12-15/ sq ft 
Less parking lot closure times  Longer parking lot closure times 

However, concrete takes over a week to cure while asphalt takes only 24-48 hours – so parking lot closure times will be prolonged for commercial property owners choosing this option. 

Concrete vs. Asphalt Driveway Cost

Regarding asphalt vs. concrete driveway cost, concrete can be considered an ideal option for homeowners. 

Here are some reasons why concrete can be more cost-effective for driveways than asphalt: 

  • Less ongoing maintenance is required because it lasts up to 50 years 
  • Smaller areas, so the higher per square footage costs are less impactful 
  • Driveways have less traffic weight and volume than parking lots, causing faster deterioration and less frequent repair costs 
  • Personalized, cleaner look, and has sharper edges  

Asphalt driveways can be considered because they’re cheaper upfront, easier to install, and less expensive to repair. Concrete is more costly upfront, has a more complex installation, and is harder to repair — which can be more financially challenging for homeowners.  

Asphalt Driveways Concrete Driveways 
Lower upfront costs Higher upfront costs 
Lasts 3-5 years with ongoing maintenance Lasts up to 50 years with no maintenance 
Easier application and cheaper repairs Complex application and costly repairs 
No access to driveways for 24-48 hours No access to driveways for a week 

Although asphalt requires more ongoing maintenance than concrete, it takes only 24-48 hours to cure, while concrete takes a week. If you’re a homeowner living in a metropolitan area with limited public parking, concrete may not be the best option for your driveway. 

Revitalize Your Parking Lot or Driveway Asphalt with Superior Asphalt

Now that you know the factors that impact asphalt vs. concrete cost and their material differences, you can decide what’s best for your home or parking lot. At Superior Asphalt, we offer asphalt maintenance services for home and property owners to keep your pavement in top shape. 

Contact us for pricing, asphalt repairs, or questions about your asphalt parking lot or driveway today! 

Related Artiles:

share this post

Related Blog Posts

Check out related blog articles with answers to common asphalt maintenance questions.

Tarmac vs Asphalt: What’s the Difference and Which One Should You Use

Tarmac vs Asphalt: What’s the Difference and Which One Should You Use

If you’ve ever looked into driveway paving or road surfacing, you’ve probably stumbled upon the age-old question: tarmac vs asphalt. What’s the difference, and which one should you choose? While the two terms are often used interchangeably, they’re not quite the same. In fact, understanding the subtle (and not-so-subtle) differences

Read More »
What is Bitumen? Everything You Need to Know

What is Bitumen? Everything You Need to Know

You’ve seen bitumen, even if you didn’t know it. It’s under your tires on highways, beneath your feet in parking lots, and layered into waterproof roofs. But what is it, really? Bitumen is a key ingredient in modern construction. It’s durable, adhesive, and built to withstand pressure and time. Still,

Read More »
What Is Asphalt Made Of? A Technical Guide

What Is Asphalt Made Of? A Technical Guide

Have you ever stopped to wonder what asphalt is made of? After all, not all asphalt is created equal. The right mix can mean the difference between a long-lasting, durable surface and one that cracks and crumbles in no time. In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to

Read More »
What are the Different Asphalt Layers?

What are the Different Asphalt Layers?

Asphalt pavement might seem like just a single layer of blacktop, but beneath the surface, there’s a carefully designed structure working hard to support traffic, withstand weather conditions, and provide long-lasting performance. Whether you’re a homeowner planning a new driveway, a property manager overseeing parking lot maintenance, or just someone

Read More »